How retirement and teaching can evolve in human populations
Mathematical models show that teaching non-kin can emerge through cultural evolution in large populations.
Retirement and teaching can evolve without kinship or inclusive fitness. This happens in populations above a certain threshold size.
Researchers used a mathematical model of stage-structured populations. Younger individuals hunt and reproduce. At some point, they retire and serve exclusively as teachers.
Oblique teaching is instruction given to non-kin. Retirement is the transition in life stage where individuals cease hunting and reproduction to teach. A global carrying capacity limits the population.
Evolutionary stable retirement rates depend on the absolute population size of a mutant type. A mutant that differs only slightly cannot invade from a minority. This means teaching cannot emerge through gradual evolution.
Teaching may emerge through cultural evolution. A sub-population might adopt a distinct norm for retirement and elder care simultaneously. This is tied to the information grandmother hypothesis of Henrich and Henrich.
In many regimes, evolution produces fewer teachers than would maximize hunting returns or the intrinsic birth rate.
Key facts
- Oblique teaching can evolve in populations above a threshold size.
- Teaching cannot emerge through gradual evolution because slight mutants cannot invade.
- Retirement and teaching may emerge through cultural evolution when a sub-population adopts new norms.