Ancient DNA shows giant crane species never went extinct
New analysis suggests the supposedly extinct Grus primigenia was actually a larger version of the modern common crane.
Ancient DNA analysis suggests the giant crane species Grus primigenia never went extinct, but instead became smaller. Researchers found that the bones previously identified as a separate species were actually from larger versions of the modern European common crane, Grus grus.
The study used DNA from 18 ancient crane bones found in England, Wales, France, Germany and the Balearic Islands.
Paleoecologist John Stewart of Bournemouth University said previous studies used only the size and shape of bones to understand these birds. He said the team suspected these large cranes represented larger, modern European common cranes.
Stewart said the mistaken identity may have been caused by the fact that cranes have large males and smaller females. This physical difference likely contributed to the speculation that there were two different species.
The research team noted that common cranes gradually became smaller after the 11th century CE. They wrote that while it is tempting to conclude this change is due to climate change or human land use change such as wetland drainage, this remains speculation.
The study was published in Royal Society Open Science. Stewart and his team aim to conduct further research to investigate the reason for the decrease in size.
Key facts
- DNA analysis reveals Grus primigenia was actually a larger version of the common crane, Grus grus.
- The study involved 18 ancient crane bones from England, Wales, France, Germany and the Balearic Islands.
- Researchers believe the size difference between males and females contributed to the mistaken identity of the species.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The study identifies the large bones once thought to be an extinct species as belonging to the modern common crane.
Positive
The use of DNA analysis has provided a more accurate picture of what these ancient bones represent.
Negative
It remains unconfirmed whether the decrease in crane size was caused by climate change or human land use changes like wetland drainage.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
