Brands shift strategies as celebrity product gifting becomes oversaturated

As the earned media value of free product mailers falls, brands are turning to affiliate platforms and expensive paid placements to reach consumers.

Brands shift strategies as celebrity product gifting becomes oversaturated
Photo: Vogue

Product seeding, where brands send gifts to celebrities and creators without guaranteed coverage, has become oversaturated. Celebrity stylist Dani Michelle said there is too much gifting, too much content, and too many paid posts.

Tyra Booker, assistant VP of integrated marketing at Rare Beauty, said she witnessed the earned media value of send-outs falling at a past job. Booker said fewer people are opening mailers and creators are less willing to post for free.

Affiliate platforms like ShopMy and LTK offer a middle ground where creators choose products from a gifting lookbook. If a creator shares a piece, they use a trackable link to earn commission on sales, allowing brands to see which posts convert. Ivy Zhang, marketing head at ShopMy, said this helps gifting work more like a sales channel than a marketing expense.

Paid placements involve a contract where a brand pays a stylist to put a specific piece on a client. An average A-list placement costs between $25,000 and $30,000, while top names can cost more than $50,000 for a single item like a necklace or sunglasses.

Payment for these placements usually goes to the stylist rather than the celebrity, and money only changes hands once a piece is worn and documented. An anonymous PR agency founder said brands prefer shots that look unplanned, such as an airport outfit, because they feel more authentic.

Key facts

  • A-list celebrity placements can cost between $25,000 and $50,000 for a single item.
  • Affiliate platforms allow creators to earn commissions through trackable links.
  • The earned media value of product mailers has been falling.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Brands are moving from organic product gifting toward affiliate models and paid stylist placements to manage visibility and costs.

Positive

Affiliate platforms provide creators with an incentive to post through commissions and help brands identify which creators drive sales.

Negative

The cost of paid placements with top celebrities can exceed $50,000 for a single item, which may not provide a return for all brands.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition