Campaigners call for staggered age of consent to protect young people

The Close the Consent Gap campaign proposes making it a criminal offence for 16 or 17-year-olds to consent to sexual activity with anyone more than three years their senior.

Campaigners call for staggered age of consent to protect young people
Photo: The Guardian

The Close the Consent Gap campaign is proposing a staggered age of consent that would make it a criminal offence for a 16- or 17-year-old to consent to sexual activity with anyone more than three years their senior. Campaign founder Layla Stone said a consensual relationship between two teenagers close in age would remain lawful, but sexual activity between a 16-year-old and a 35-year-old would be prohibited.

Barrister Charlotte Proudman, who specialises in law regarding violence against women and girls, said the current law does not adequately recognise the significant power imbalance between children and much older adults. She noted that the law treats 16 as the point at which a child can legally consent to sexual activity with someone of any age, rather than taking the age difference into account. Proudman said a staggered age of consent would place responsibility on the older adult instead of requiring a teenage complainant to demonstrate grooming, coercion or exploitation.

Claire Waxman, the victims’ commissioner for England and Wales, has called for serious conversations regarding the potential for legislative change. A staggered consent law is one route favoured by campaigners and supported by some Labour MPs.

Researchers have questioned the evidence for such a change. Professor Roger Ingham, director of the Centre for Sexual Health Research at the University of Southampton, said there was no strong evidence that different countries with different ages had completely different patterns of sexual behaviour or outcomes. He said tinkering with the law could divert attention from other efforts, such as better sex education, and risked young people avoiding contraceptive advice or other support if their relationship was deemed illegal.

Dr Sophie King-Hill, an associate professor at the University of Birmingham, said it could create a false sense of protection and risked children not coming forward because they would be worried they had broken the law. She said it is important to be careful because changing the law could inadvertently make things worse or oversimplify a complex problem.

Key facts

  • The Close the Consent Gap campaign proposes making it a criminal offence for 16 or 17-year-olds to have sexual activity with anyone more than three years older.
  • Professor Roger Ingham noted there is no strong evidence that different age-of-consent laws result in different sexual behaviour patterns.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Campaigners are proposing a staggered age of consent to address power imbalances between young people and older adults.

Positive

A staggered age of consent would place responsibility on the older adult rather than requiring a teenage complainant to demonstrate grooming or exploitation.

Negative

Researchers warned that changing the law could cause young people to avoid seeking contraceptive advice or support if they fear their relationship is illegal.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Australia sanctions Israeli settlers and construction firm over West Bank expansion
Next storyAustralia sanctions Israeli settlers and construction firm over West Bank expansion

All sections

Edition