Former US trade officials urge court to strike down Trump's Canada tariffs
Three former senior U.S. trade officials, including NAFTA architect Carla Hills, argue the administration is using an obsolete law to bypass congressional safeguards.

Three former senior U.S. trade officials, including Carla Hills, a key architect of the North American Free Trade Agreement, have urged a federal court to strike down President Donald Trump's 50 percent tariffs on Canadian goods. In a legal brief filed with the U.S. Court of International Trade on November 11, the group argued the administration is relying on Section 338 of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, a law they contend has been superseded.
The officials, which includes former deputy U.S. trade representative Alan Wolff and former general counsel Warren Maruyama, argue that Section 338 is effectively dead. They contend that Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 provides the proper mechanism for challenging unfair trade practices and includes requirements for investigations, consultations, and public input that Section 338 lacks.
The brief supports a lawsuit brought by Gellert Global Group, a New Jersey-based food importer, which is represented by the Liberty Justice Center. Trump announced the additional 50 percent tariffs on nearly $20 billion worth of Canadian imports on July 20, with the measures taking effect on August 22. Affected products included wine, furniture, hockey equipment, clothing, and machinery.
Canada responded by announcing retaliatory tariffs of 15, 25, and 50 percent on U.S. imports, including dairy products, steel, furniture, and electronics, which took effect on September 8. The former officials warned that allowing the administration to use Section 338 would provide a massive weapon that could drive up prices for tens of millions of U.S. households.
Sara Albrecht, chair and CEO of the Liberty Justice Center, said the participation of Hills, Wolff, and Maruyama provides the court with perspective on where presidential authority ends. Lachlan Wolfers, a partner and national leader of KPMG Law in Canada, said the administration is relying on a little-known, never-tested power.
Key facts
- Three former U.S. trade officials are calling for the 50 percent tariffs on Canadian goods to be struck down and refunds issued to American importers.
- The tariffs affect nearly $20 billion worth of Canadian imports, including wine, furniture, and hockey equipment.
- The legal challenge argues the administration bypassed congressional safeguards by invoking Section 338 of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 instead of Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974.
Three perspectives
Neutral
Three former U.S. trade officials have filed a legal brief urging a court to strike down 50 percent tariffs on Canadian imports.
Positive
The former officials are calling for the tariffs to be struck down and for refunds to be issued to American importers.
Negative
The tariffs, affecting an estimated $20 billion in Canadian imports, could drive up prices for tens of millions of U.S. households.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.