NZ Super Debate

Economists and politicians weigh in on the sustainability of New Zealand's superannuation system, with some calling for a raise in the eligibility age. The current system costs about $26 billion a year, and its expense as a share of GDP is rising.

New Zealand's young people may be frustrated to pay for increasingly expensive NZ Super while missing out on benefits like free education, says economist Cameron Bagrie. The cost of NZ Super is about $26 billion a year, out of $130 billion in tax revenue.

Alec Waugh from the KiwiSaver Annuities New Zealand Superannuation Protection Society argues that changing the system could have unintended consequences, such as more people on the unemployment benefit or seeking hardship grants.

National leader Christopher Luxon and Finance spokesperson Nicola Willis have committed to discussing the retirement system in a cross-party accord with Labour, rather than making changes to the superannuation age before the election.

Labour's Finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds says the party will not increase the superannuation age from 65, citing affordable choices. Edmonds and Willis have agreed to work together on the issue.

Other countries have higher retirement ages, such as 67 in the US, UK, and Denmark. New Zealand's retirement age is currently 65.

The debate around NZ Super comes as National releases its fiscal policy, which does not include plans to raise the superannuation age.

Economist Cameron Bagrie says the argument that NZ Super is one of the cheapest schemes ignores the fact that its cost as a share of GDP is rising. He argues that this increase will require choices about government expenditure or tax increases.

Key facts

  • NZ Super costs about $26 billion a year
  • The system's expense as a share of GDP is rising
  • National and Labour have agreed to a cross-party accord on the retirement system
  • Other countries have higher retirement ages, such as 67

Three perspectives

Neutral

The debate around NZ Super highlights the need for a sustainable solution. The cross-party accord between National and Labour may lead to a more comprehensive approach to the issue. The outcome of these discussions will be important to watch.

Positive

The commitment to a cross-party accord is a constructive step towards addressing the challenges facing NZ Super. Economists and politicians are working together to find a solution that balances the needs of different generations.

Negative

The lack of concrete plans to address the rising cost of NZ Super is a concern. The system's expense as a share of GDP is increasing, and difficult choices may be required to ensure its sustainability.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyUS ambassador hits back at Auckland mayor Wayne Brown over democracy comments

All sections

Edition