US ambassador hits back at Auckland mayor Wayne Brown over democracy comments

Jared Novelly responded on X after Brown said democracy had "had its day" and praised China's economic growth.

US Ambassador Jared Novelly has criticised Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown after Brown praised China and said democracy has "had its day".

Posting on X, Novelly said that the mayor's statements showed he had not made the cut for a New Zealand government intelligence briefing.

Novelly compared democracy to Auckland traffic, saying democracy could be messy, slow and frustrating, but no one would recommend getting rid of it, just as no one would recommend removing the traffic lights.

Novelly said the US and New Zealand built two successful democracies by giving people a say, and he said economic growth mattered, as did freedom, accountability and the right to vote leaders out.

Brown told Stuff that democracy had had its day and that it was time for something else, and said New Zealand should copy places that were going well.

Brown said he was not suggesting a massive change in how people are elected, but was talking about New Zealand's version of democracy, which he said had been "gamed".

Key facts

  • Novelly posted on X that the mayor had not made the cut for an intelligence briefing.
  • Brown said democracy had "had its day" and told Stuff it was time for something else.
  • Brown said the economy in China had gone up over the last 40 years while Labour and National had presided over a decay of the economy.

Three perspectives

Neutral

US Ambassador Jared Novelly publicly criticised Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown after Brown praised China's economic growth and said democracy had had its day.

Positive

Novelly said that in a democracy people are free to disagree with the mayor, as Aucklanders and New Zealanders are free to disagree with him.

Negative

Novelly said the mayor's statements showed he had not made the cut for an intelligence briefing.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition