UK regulations could affect 150 platforms including LegoPlay and Spotify

Proposed online safety rules targeting recommender systems and user-generated content may cover up to 150 platforms, according to sources.

UK regulations could affect 150 platforms including LegoPlay and Spotify
Photo: The Guardian

Proposed regulations could affect up to 150 platforms, including LegoPlay, Spotify, and eBay, according to sources. The regulations will be sent for cabinet signoff this week, and culture secretary Lisa Nandy is expected to lay them in parliament in December. The ban is set to come into force in March.

Online safety minister Ian Murray said platforms must prevent harms created by algorithms, recommender systems, or conversations with strangers. He said platforms like YouTube Kids and Lego Play would need to demonstrate they do not have harmful algorithms. Murray told MPs that platforms which redesigned their services to remove harmful or addictive functions would have a route to removing themselves from the banned list.

Tech companies, industry groups, and MPs have been briefed that the working proposal focuses on recommender systems and user-generated content. Spotify could technically be in scope if the proposals are enacted, though the music streaming site has sought reassurances that it would not face a ban because it is not primarily a social platform. A company source said Spotify's messaging is restricted to contact only with known friends and family for users who are 16 and older.

Industry figures have expressed concerns that the regulation is too broad. One industry source said a situation where eBay, Lego, YouTube Kids, and Spotify are not clear whether they comply is unsustainable. Tech industry bodies have told the government that platforms such as YouTube Kids cease to function without the recommender system, making it impossible for them to comply with the proposed off-ramp.

Ministers are also looking at a second tranche of regulations in the spring which could cover e-commerce platforms such as Vinted, eBay, and Depop. Ian Murray confirmed to MPs last week that the government is looking at those sites for the next tranche of regulations which examines features and functions. Following Nandy's confirmation that the government was looking to bring Vinted and other e-commerce platforms into scope, officials held a call with retailers on Tuesday where several are understood to have strongly contested the plans.

Key facts

  • Regulations under consideration could affect up to 150 platforms, including LegoPlay, Spotify, and eBay.
  • The regulations are expected to be laid in parliament in December and come into force in March.
  • A second tranche of regulations covering e-commerce platforms like Vinted and Depop is expected in the spring.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The government is considering regulations for up to 150 platforms that focus on recommender systems and user-generated content.

Positive

Platforms that redesign their services to remove harmful or addictive functions would have a route to removing themselves from the banned list.

Negative

Tech companies have told the government that removing recommender algorithms would make it impossible for their sites to function.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Singapore to transition to satellite-based road charging in 2027
Next storySingapore to transition to satellite-based road charging in 2027

All sections

Edition