Pakistani farmers sue German energy and cement firms over climate damages
Forty farmers from Sindh province are seeking compensation from RWE and Heidelberg Materials for impacts caused by 2022 flooding.

Forty farmers from Pakistan's southern Sindh province are suing German energy firm RWE and cement maker Heidelberg Materials in a bid to make big polluters pay damages for climate impacts. The plaintiffs, including Abdul Hafeez Khoso, were devastated by flooding in 2022 that they described as apocalyptic.
The lawsuit is backed by Pakistani and European organisations seeking to extract climate damages from corporations. Lawyers say a ruling requiring a company to pay compensation proportionate to its greenhouse gas emissions would be a major breakthrough. The case builds on a German judiciary move last year in a case brought by a Peruvian farmer against RWE.
Abdul Hafeez Khoso, who lives in the district of Jacobabad, estimates he lost $14,000 in assets, including his house, livestock, and 40 acres of crops. Munawar Khatoon, a landowner, said the floods struck just before the wheat harvest, submerging seeds and wiping out her family's main source of income.
RWE and Heidelberg Materials both call the claims in the suit unfounded. Heidelberg Materials said its operations comply with German laws and that firms cannot be expected to face different standards retroactively. RWE described the lawsuit as an attempt to shift climate policy demands to German courtrooms.
The 2022 floods hit a third of Pakistan, killed 1,700 people, and affected 30 million Pakistanis. The civil process for this lawsuit is expected to take years.
Key facts
- Forty farmers from Sindh province are suing RWE and Heidelberg Materials.
- The plaintiffs estimate the companies contributed 0.68 percent and 0.12 percent to global industrial emissions respectively.
- The 2022 floods in Pakistan killed 1,700 people and affected 30 million people.
Three perspectives
Neutral
Pakistani farmers are suing German companies RWE and Heidelberg Materials in a civil process that is expected to take years.
Positive
The lawsuit is supported by organisations hoping to win compensation and build international efforts to extract climate damages from corporations.
Negative
The 2022 floods killed 1,700 people and left farmers like Abdul Hafeez Khoso unable to repay debts after losing $14,000 in assets.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
