Southern Cross declines Mohs surgery for chef Simon Gault

Celebrity chef Simon Gault expressed disappointment after Southern Cross declined to fund a specialist-recommended cancer surgery.

Southern Cross declines Mohs surgery for chef Simon Gault
Photo: 1News

Celebrity chef Simon Gault said he was disappointed with how his Southern Cross policy responded to skin cancer. His specialist recommended Mohs surgery for a greater chance of removing all the cancer, but Southern Cross declined the application. The insurer offered to cover a standard excision instead, but declined Gault's request to pay the difference between the standard excision and the Mohs surgery.

Southern Cross tightened its criteria for Mohs surgery in December. Tim Fairbrother, founder of Rival Wealth, said the insurer declined the specific surgery because it did not meet current funding criteria, similar to how they do not cover non-Pharmac drugs.

Health insurance premiums have risen almost 75% in the past five years. Jon-Paul Hale, founder of Willowgrove Consulting, said the sums people would need to save to truly self-insure would be unmanageable for most. He noted a recent client claim for early-stage breast cancer was worth $265,000 in 12 months.

Hale calculated that an average person with medical insurance from age 20 to 70 would spend about $230,000 on premiums over their lifetime. He said that as people get older, it could make sense to take on more cover themselves. For a couple aged 55, spending on specialists and tests cover could be about $250 a month.

Russell Hutchinson of Chatswood Consulting said anyone planning to self-fund healthcare would need to save quite a bit for large health problems. He said medical insurance helps with infrequent events at very high costs, which represent catastrophic risk. Liz Koh, founder of Enrich Retirement, said people worried about premiums could consider taking a higher excess to make a substantial difference to the cost.

Key facts

  • Southern Cross declined to fund Mohs surgery for Simon Gault after tightening its criteria in December.
  • Health insurance premiums have increased by almost 75% over the last five years.
  • An average person may spend approximately $230,000 on premiums between the ages of 20 and 70.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The debate over whether to hold health insurance or save for medical costs involves weighing premium rises against the risk of high-cost medical events.

Positive

Taking a higher excess can make a substantial difference to the premiums charged to policyholders.

Negative

Southern Cross declined to cover the specific Mohs surgery recommended by Simon Gault's specialist.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

United States loses measles-free status amid worst outbreak since 1991
Next storyUnited States loses measles-free status amid worst outbreak since 1991

All sections

Edition