Early Covid containment efforts were doomed to fail, inquiry finds
The public inquiry's 245-page report says the virus spread largely unchecked in the first months of the pandemic.
The public inquiry has found that early efforts to contain coronavirus were doomed to fail. Its report, which runs to 245 pages, examines everything from border controls to how well contact tracing worked.
Ministers said this was because testing capacity was being overwhelmed. NHS Test and Trace was launched two months later. Across the UK, more than £30bn was ultimately spent on testing, tracing and isolating during the pandemic.
The inquiry said the four UK nations were effectively blind to how quickly Covid was spreading in those early months. Inquiry chair Baroness Hallett said the UK should have been better prepared and should have learnt lessons from countries with experience of other infectious disease outbreaks, such as Sars. Hong Kong, South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan had established systems ready to go, unlike the UK. The UK had run simulation exercises in the years before Covid, including Exercise Cygnus into a flu pandemic and Exercise Alice into Mers, and both identified problems relating to test, trace or isolation that appear not to have been fully acted on.
The report also asks whether the government could have used non-government testing facilities in hospitals, universities and the private sector from the start, rather than relying on 12 government labs. It says many people asked to isolate felt forgotten and let down by the lack of practical or financial support. Estimates in the early months suggested less than half of people were complying with isolation rules. Statutory sick pay was changed, but £500 payments for those on low incomes were not introduced in England until September, and later in Scotland and Wales.
The report says the UK lacked a clear strategy for border control early in the pandemic, leaving the country in an extremely vulnerable position. By April 2020, 93% of countries had put border measures in place, whereas the UK only asked travellers from high-risk areas to self-isolate for 14 days. The report says border controls were a critical gap and recommends that international border control measures be in place at the earliest stages of a pandemic.
Three different apps were developed during Covid, which the inquiry says took up valuable time, and it recommends a UK-wide digital tool for any future outbreak. In summer 2021, around 7% of UK adults were told to self-isolate over a seven-day period, which the press dubbed the pingdemic, and Treasury estimates suggested this may have reduced economic growth by as much as 0.3% that month.
Key facts
- Community testing and contact tracing were abandoned in mid-March 2020.
- More than £30bn was spent across the UK on testing, tracing and isolating.
- By April 2020, 93% of countries had put border measures in place.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The public inquiry's 245-page report examines the UK's Covid response, from border controls to contact tracing.
Positive
The inquiry says digital tools such as smartphone apps can have a significant impact on reducing the spread of infection and recommends a UK-wide digital tool for future outbreaks.
Negative
The inquiry finds the virus was allowed to spread virtually unchecked in the first few months, costing lives, and that early containment efforts were doomed to fail.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.