Experts criticise Healey's 'scattergun' budget

The Institute for Fiscal Studies says the chancellor has left himself a mountain to climb by avoiding major tax and spending decisions.

Experts criticise Healey's 'scattergun' budget
Photo: The Guardian

The chancellor has delivered a budget that experts have described as 'scattergun' and lacking in major tax and spending decisions. The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said Healey has left himself a mountain to climb.

The IFS said Healey would have needed to set aside an additional £28bn a year to offset inflation's impact on future spending and to meet the target of spending 3% of GDP on defence by 2030. Helen Miller, the IFS director, said the chancellor has opened the way to a spending review that could look 'pretty brutal' for some departments, including real-term budget cuts.

Healey has proposed a £100 winter cost of living payment for most households to ease costs. He also doubled the surcharge banks pay on profits from 3% to 6% for 15 months.

The Resolution Foundation said the budget failed to target energy support to the households that need it most. Ruth Curtice, the organisation's chief executive, said the cost of living support is being spread far too thinly and will leave some families facing higher energy bills than during the last energy price shock.

Regarding welfare, Healey said there will be a reduction in the benefits bill in a 'Labour way'. He pointed to forthcoming reviews from Alan Milburn on employment support for young people and from Stephen Timms on disability benefits.

Healey also addressed growth, stating that while Brexit hit growth and trade, the challenge is to make the best of an economy that has been remarkably resilient.

Key facts

  • The IFS said Healey needs an additional £28bn a year to offset inflation and hit defence spending targets.
  • Healey doubled the bank profit surcharge from 3% to 6% for 15 months.
  • The chancellor promised a £100 winter cost of living payment for most households.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The chancellor's budget includes a £100 winter cost of living payment and a doubled bank surcharge while facing criticism over its focus.

Positive

Healey has doubled the surcharge banks pay on their profits from 3% to 6% for 15 months to help fund measures.

Negative

The Resolution Foundation said the chancellor delivered a scattergun budget that spread cost of living support too thinly.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Burnham and Badenoch clash over welfare and youth employment at PMQs
Next storyBurnham and Badenoch clash over welfare and youth employment at PMQs

All sections

Edition