Trump's treatment of Canada becomes central to U.S. midterm election debate

As the U.S. midterm elections approach, Canada has become a significant part of the political debate south of the border.

Trump's treatment of Canada becomes central to U.S. midterm election debate
Photo: The Globe and Mail

As the U.S. midterm elections approach, Canada has become a significant part of the political debate south of the border. Candidates in states bordering Canada are running to check the President's power by seeking control of Congress. Eight U.S. Senators will be elected this year in states that border Canada, representing nearly a quarter of the total.

In several states, candidates are pointing to Donald Trump's treatment of Canada as a reason for voters to turn against him and the Republican party. In Idaho, independent candidate Todd Achilles is challenging incumbent Republican Jim Risch, stating that nearly 40 per cent of Idaho exports went to Canada last year. Achilles said the President's treatment of Canada has become a punchline that makes people question the direction of the country.

The economic impact of trade policies is felt differently across the northern border. In Maine, the focus is on Canadian concrete and road salt, while New Hampshire faces the disappearance of Canadian tourists. Michigan deals with the impact on Labatt beer, Minnesota faces rising costs for Canadian construction materials, Montana faces fertilizer costs, and Idaho worries about dairy exports.

Polling shows that tariffs are a low priority in terms of popularity, ranking lowest among 14 key policies pursued by the administration. Voters often link these tariffs to inflation and the affordability crisis. While roughly 60 per cent of Americans would prefer a positive relationship with Canada over protectionist policies, some Republican voters disagree. In Montana, nearly 60 per cent of Republican voters said they felt hurt by tariffs but believed the dispute with Canada was warranted.

Republican candidate for Senate in Montana, Kurt Alme, has campaigned on the message that Canada has not played fair for too long and that someone needed to push back for a level playing field. Conversely, Jim Lottsfeldt, a campaign strategist in Anchorage, said the President's mistreatment of Canada has helped undermine the broader Republican agenda.

Key facts

  • Eight U.S. Senators in states bordering Canada will be elected this year.
  • Nearly 40 per cent of Idaho exports went to Canada last year.
  • Tariffs rank lowest in popularity among 14 key policies pursued by the Trump administration.
  • Roughly 60 per cent of Americans would choose a positive relationship with Canada over protectionist policies.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Canada has become an unlikely character in the U.S. campaign as candidates and voters discuss trade and tariffs.

Positive

Approximately 60 per cent of Americans would choose a positive relationship with Canada over protectionist policies.

Negative

Voters see the President's tariffs as a top reason for inflation and the ongoing affordability crisis.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Carney says Canada may turn to Chinese automakers if US trade talks fail
Next storyCarney says Canada may turn to Chinese automakers if US trade talks fail

All sections

Edition