Justices to hear case on unpled affirmative defenses
The case will determine whether an affirmative defense may be asserted as a basis for summary judgment if not presented earlier in a pleading.

Justices agreed to hear a case in March to determine whether an affirmative defense may be asserted as a basis for summary judgment if not presented earlier in a pleading.
The case involves Jasmine Younge, who sued the Fulton County District Attorney’s Office for civil rights violations after she was fired in July 2019. Younge says she was dismissed about two weeks after telling District Attorney Paul Howard that she was pregnant.
The DA’s office moved for summary judgment based on a personal-staff exemption defense that it had not asserted in its answer. The office explained that it did not learn of the defense until its lawyer began drafting the summary judgment motion.
The 11th Circuit affirmed the district court, finding that Younge had not suffered prejudice from the late assertion of the personal staff exemption. The circuit court noted Younge could not identify any additional discovery she would have pursued had the defense been asserted earlier.
Younge argues that allowing a summary judgment motion based upon an unpled affirmative defense permits a defendant to circumvent the requirements of Rule 15(a)(2) for amending a pleading and Rule 16(b)(4) for modifying a scheduling order.
The DA’s office asserts the prejudice standard is correct to resolve cases on the merits and to avoid resolution on the basis of technical or formalistic application of the rules.
Key facts
- Justices will hear the case to determine if an unpled affirmative defense can be used for summary judgment.
- Jasmine Younge sued the Fulton County District Attorney’s Office alleging she was fired due to pregnancy.
- The 11th Circuit affirmed a summary judgment for the DA’s office because Younge was not prejudiced by the late defense.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The case will determine whether an affirmative defense may be asserted as a basis for summary judgment if not presented earlier in a pleading.
Positive
The DA’s office maintains its position will help resolve cases on the merits rather than through technical applications of the rules.
Negative
Younge argues that the current practice allows defendants to circumvent requirements for amending pleadings and modifying scheduling orders.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.