National-led coalition accused of worsening health underfunding

Critics say chronic underfunding has cratered under the coalition as shortages of beds, nurses, and doctors impact care.

National-led coalition accused of worsening health underfunding
Photo: The Guardian

The National-led coalition has been accused of letting chronic underfunding worsen care shortfalls across New Zealand. Critics say the underfunding of the health system, which was exposed during the Covid pandemic, has further cratered under the coalition.

Dr Katie Ben, an anaesthetist and president of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, says there are not enough beds, nurses, doctors, or space at every level of the roster. In Nelson, where she works, there are 17 fewer nurses than three years ago, and surgical wards are run from an earthquake-prone building earmarked for replacement at least a decade ago.

Healthcare professionals say their ability to provide safe care is being compromised, and many are defecting to Australia where pay could be up to 30% higher. Dr Ben says a two-tier healthcare system is emerging where only those who can afford it can be seen, driven by a shortage of staff, the rollback of Māori-access initiatives, and millions being directed to private hospitals.

In Diamond Harbour, Jane Harrison and her husband Shaun Fitzgerald, 65, are both on disability assistance. Harrison, 60, says Fitzgerald, a former roofer, is waiting for surgery to fuse his vertebrae after an August 2025 operation for spinal stenosis was not as effective as hoped.

Harrison says she has struggled to find assistance for her long Covid and has found doctor visits expensive. She says they should not be bed-bound and desperately trying to eke out money from the government.

Minister Brown says the health system is measurably improving. He stated that three-quarters of emergency department patients are seen within the target of six hours, and that elective surgery waiting times and childhood immunisation rates have improved. Brown added that spending more on private hospitals has resulted in 40,000 extra elective surgeries, though he conceded the system remains under pressure.

Key facts

  • The National-led coalition is accused of letting chronic health underfunding worsen.
  • Minister Brown says three-quarters of emergency department patients are seen within a six-hour target.
  • Dr Katie Ben reports 17 fewer nurses in Nelson compared to three years ago.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Data shows that in comparison to healthcare in other countries in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, New Zealand's health expenditure per capita and the number of practising nurses are above average, but the number of hospital beds and doctors are below average.

Positive

Minister Brown says spending more on private hospitals has resulted in 40,000 extra elective surgeries.

Negative

Nurses and doctors say their ability to provide safe care is being compromised and many are moving to Australia for pay that could be up to 30% higher.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition