High Court begins hearing challenges to social media ban for children under 16

Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project are challenging the constitutional validity of the federal government's ban on children under 16 using social media.

High Court begins hearing challenges to social media ban for children under 16
Photo: Outlook India

The High Court of Australia has commenced a two-day constitutional hearing examining the legal validity of a federal law banning children under 16 from maintaining active social media profiles. The challenge is brought forward by the social media platform Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project, a digital rights group.

The Digital Freedom Project, led by New South Wales parliamentarian John Ruddick, argues the ban violates children's right to communicate freely and infringes upon the Constitution's implied freedom of political communication and democratic discourse. Lawyers for the challengers contend that while protecting minors is a legitimate objective, a mandatory blanket prohibition acts as an unconstitutional restriction on freedoms.

The Commonwealth government argues the laws prioritise the safety and well-being of children over the commercial interests of technology companies.

The ban, which took effect on 10 December last year, requires 10 platforms to take reasonable steps to prevent users under 16 from accessing their services. These platforms include Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Reddit, Snapchat, X, Kick, Threads and Twitch. Companies facing serious or repeated breaches of the law face fines of up to A$99 million.

Reddit said it shares the government's goal of protecting young people but argued more effective alternatives are available. Reddit's chief communications officer Adam Collins said the platform will continue to comply with the law while advocating for youth safety measures.

The eSafety Commissioner has launched investigations into alleged non-compliance by Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok and YouTube. The restrictions do not apply to WhatsApp, online gaming platforms such as Roblox and Discord, or educational services such as YouTube Kids and Google Classroom.

Key facts

  • The High Court is conducting a two-day hearing regarding the constitutional validity of the under-16 social media ban.
  • Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project filed separate challenges against the law.
  • Non-compliant tech giants could face fines of up to A$99 million.
  • The ban applies to 10 platforms including Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The High Court is examining whether the federal social media ban for children under 16 violates constitutional freedoms of communication and expression.

Positive

The government maintains the legislation is a necessary measure to shield children from addictive algorithms, cyberbullying, and unregulated digital exposure.

Negative

Critics and legal challengers argue the blanket ban is an overly broad tool that zones young Australians out of digital public spaces.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Australia sanctions Israeli settlers and construction firm over West Bank expansion
Next storyAustralia sanctions Israeli settlers and construction firm over West Bank expansion

All sections

Edition