IGF jurors refuse to vote for games using generative AI

Nineteen members of the Independent Games Festival jury released a statement declining to vote for any game that uses generative AI in any capacity.

IGF jurors refuse to vote for games using generative AI
Photo: Ars Technica

Nineteen members of the 50-plus-member Independent Games Festival jury released a signed statement on Monday declining to vote for any game that uses generative AI in any capacity. The group of jurors called for the IGF to adopt a strong anti-AI policy for future years that disallows games containing any AI-generated work. They noted a significant increase in games developed with generative AI tools and cited ecological, economic, psychological, and labor harms.

Developer House House admitted that LLMs were used sparingly near the end of the development of Big Walk to help work through difficult technical challenges and bugs. The studio said the usage represents well under 0.1% of the game's code. The use stemmed from a Unity engine bug involving infinite length shadows, which a Unity engineer determined was not possible to fix. House House consulted an LLM chatbot that suggested a fix, which developers then modified extensively into 10 lines of code.

House House said it did not disclose the LLM usage for the Steam release earlier this year because Valve does not request disclosure of code or chatbot usage. The studio is making the disclosure now because it has become a matter of public interest.

The disclosure caused disappointment among some IGF judges who had previously praised the game. Jurist Austin Walker called the game an achievement and remarkable, while fellow jurist Damon Reece said the game was seriously special to him. However, both Walker and Reece said that even minimal use of AI tools overrode their respect for the work.

Reaction to the disclosure has been divided. The game's Steam page received over 400 negative reviews, though Steam's tools have limited the impact on its overall Very Positive reception.

Key facts

  • House House used LLMs for well under 0.1% of Big Walk's code to fix a Unity engine bug.
  • The IGF jury group urged the organization to adopt a policy disallowing games containing any AI-generated work.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The Independent Games Festival jury is debating whether to disqualify games that use generative AI tools in their development.

Positive

House House provided a public disclosure of its minimal AI usage and stated it will work to have a more comprehensive AI policy for future games.

Negative

Some IGF jurors stated that even minimal use of AI tools overrides their respect for a game, and Big Walk's Steam page was targeted with over 400 negative reviews.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyRockstar Games staff sacked over Discord leaks, tribunal hears

All sections

Edition