Judge dismisses Trump defamation lawsuit over Epstein letter

A judge threw out Donald Trump's $10 billion lawsuit against Dow Jones and Rupert Murdoch, ruling the case failed to prove actual malice.

Judge dismisses Trump defamation lawsuit over Epstein letter
Photo: CNBC

A judge has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by Donald Trump against Dow Jones and Rupert Murdoch, ruling the case cannot be refiled. Judge Darrin Gayles threw out the $10 billion suit with prejudice, finding it runs counter to the First Amendment.

Trump had previously sought $20 billion in damages before refiling the suit for $10 billion. The legal action followed a report regarding a letter allegedly written by Trump to Jeffrey Epstein in 2003. Trump has denied writing or signing the letter, which reportedly included suggestive language and a hand-drawn outline of a woman's body.

In a 20-page ruling, Gayles noted the investigation that led to the story and said the lawsuit was grasping at straws to manufacture flaws in the work. The judge wrote that Trump's legal team did not prove the defendants acted with actual malice, which is the legal requirement to show a defendant knew a statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.

Trump's team argued that because he denied writing the letter when contacted, the report should not have been published. Gayles wrote that if such a denial blocked publication, journalists would be immediately blocked from publishing contradictory press, which flies in the face of the American privilege to speak one's mind.

The letter, which features a signature at the bottom, allegedly contained a joking reference that enigmas never age and ended with the words: "A pal is a wonderful thing. Happy Birthday - and may every day be another wonderful secret".

Key facts

  • Judge Darrin Gayles dismissed Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit with prejudice.
  • Trump denied writing a 2003 birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein that contained suggestive language and a drawing of a woman's body.
  • The court found that Trump's team did not prove the defendants acted with actual malice.

Three perspectives

Neutral

A judge dismissed Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against Dow Jones and Rupert Murdoch regarding a letter allegedly written to Jeffrey Epstein.

Positive

The judge's ruling protected the First Amendment and the freedom of the press.

Negative

Trump's legal team failed to prove that the defendants acted with actual malice in their reporting.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Carney says Canada may turn to Chinese automakers if US trade talks fail
Next storyCarney says Canada may turn to Chinese automakers if US trade talks fail

All sections

Edition