UK considers formal slavery apology as Dutch experience warns of backlash

Andy Burnham's pledge for structured dialogue with former colonies follows the Dutch model, where a state apology prompted political rows and disillusionment.

UK considers formal slavery apology as Dutch experience warns of backlash
Photo: The Guardian

Andy Burnham has pledged to seek a structured dialogue with former colonies to help shape Britain's first formal state apology for slavery. This marks the UK's first tentative step down a path the Netherlands began five years ago.

The Dutch experience may provide a preview for London as it weighs its words while ruling out support for reparations. In the Netherlands, apologising did not draw a line under the past for everyone and prompted a political backlash, disillusion among many descendants, and a row over what justice really means.

In December 2022, Mark Rutte made a landmark apology for the Netherlands' role in the slave trade, recognising slavery as a crime against humanity. He admitted the Dutch state had enabled, encouraged, and profited from slavery for more than 250 years.

While the Dutch government ruled out direct financial reparations to individuals or former colonies, it backed its apology with a €200m fund. This money was divided between state-led educational and awareness programmes, such as overhauling school curriculums, and social initiatives and community grants to grassroots groups.

The apology was criticised by some activists and descendants as hasty, paternalistic, and made without real consultation. Roy Kaikusi Groenberg, of the Honour and Recovery Foundation, called the prime minister's declaration a neocolonial belch.

Key facts

  • Andy Burnham pledged to seek a structured dialogue with former colonies to shape Britain's first formal state apology for slavery.
  • Mark Rutte apologised in December 2022 for the Dutch state's role in the slave trade.
  • The Dutch government provided a €200m fund to support its apology.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The UK is considering a formal state apology for slavery, following a process previously undertaken by the Netherlands.

Positive

The Dutch government backed its apology with a €200m fund for educational programmes and community grants.

Negative

The Dutch apology prompted a political backlash and was described by some as a neocolonial belch.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Burnham and Badenoch clash over welfare and youth employment at PMQs
Next storyBurnham and Badenoch clash over welfare and youth employment at PMQs

All sections

Edition