Law firm finds cultural issues at Neso following whistleblower allegations

An investigation by Eversheds Sutherlands found significant governance and control issues despite finding no evidence of inappropriate influence over grid operational decisions.

Law firm finds cultural issues at Neso following whistleblower allegations
Photo: The Guardian

An external investigation into the National Energy System Operator (Neso) has identified significant cultural, governance and control issues. The law firm Eversheds Sutherlands, which was tasked with investigating whistleblower allegations, found no evidence that inappropriate influence was exerted over operational decisions or that engineers were warned against leaving a paper trail of their efforts to stabilise the grid.

The investigation followed claims that Neso executives covered up blackout risks during a June heatwave. Whistleblowers alleged the grid was becoming unmanageable and that the corporate affairs team interfered with control room decisions to protect the reputation of the government-owned operator. The revolt included internal complaints, the leak of documents to the press, and accusations of whistleblower intimidation.

The June heatwave caused grid frequency levels to fall below normal limits, requiring emergency assistance from neighbouring countries. Near-record temperatures caused electricity demand for air-conditioning to surge, while a high pressure heat dome slowed wind turbines and caused unplanned outages at gas and nuclear plants across Europe.

Investigators found high levels of stress and concern among control room engineers regarding the balance of the power system as renewable energy replaces fossil fuel plants. Staff felt their concerns went largely unheard because of the need to keep the government and regulators happy, and some believed senior executives did not understand the pressures faced by frontline staff.

Tim Jarvis, the chief executive of the regulator Ofgem, said the investigation raised concerning issues about working culture and practices at Neso. A separate, ongoing Ofgem investigation will examine whether identified cultural issues affected operational decision-making, system security, or consumer energy costs. Findings from Ofgem are expected no later than 31 March 2027.

Neso chief executive Fintan Slye said the report was constructive and that the company will act on recommendations and work with trade unions.

Key facts

  • Eversheds Sutherlands found no evidence of inappropriate influence over Neso's operational decisions.
  • The investigation identified significant cultural, governance and control issues within Neso.
  • Ofgem will publish its separate investigation findings no later than 31 March 2027.

Three perspectives

Neutral

An independent investigation by Eversheds Sutherlands found no evidence of operational interference at Neso but identified significant cultural and governance issues.

Positive

Neso chief executive Fintan Slye said the company will act on the report's recommendations and work with trade unions to ensure colleagues feel heard.

Negative

Whistleblowers accused Neso of a cover-up regarding blackout risks and alleged that staff faced high levels of stress and intimidation.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Fed minutes show hawkish debate over potential larger rate hikes
Next storyFed minutes show hawkish debate over potential larger rate hikes

All sections

Edition