NC appeals court questions dismissal of voter ID and tax cap lawsuit
Judges questioned why the NAACP was not given another chance to present evidence ahead of a vote on constitutional amendments.

North Carolina appeals court judges questioned whether the NAACP should be granted another opportunity to present its case on Wednesday. The judges also raised the possibility that the upcoming election could change the course of the lawsuit.
The lawsuit involves two constitutional amendments that voters will decide on next Tuesday. One proposal would expand the state's constitutional photo ID requirement to all voting, including absentee ballots. The other would cap the state income tax rate at 3.5%, down from 7%.
The NAACP argues that the state lawmakers who put the 2018 amendments on the ballot lacked authority because the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the legislative maps used to elect them were unconstitutional racial gerrymanders. Attorney Kym Meyer said the organization is fighting to have its evidence heard as prescribed by the Supreme Court.
Attorneys for Republican legislative leaders defended the dismissal of the challenge by a three-judge Superior Court panel. Martin Warf, representing the legislative leaders, said that if the amendments pass, the case would be rendered moot and they would move to dismiss it.
The legal battle dates back to 2018 when voters approved amendments requiring photo ID for in-person voting and lowering the income tax cap from 10% to 7%. While a Wake County judge struck down those amendments in 2019, the state Court of Appeals later reversed that decision.
Key facts
- Voters will decide on photo ID requirements and an income tax cap next Tuesday.
- The NAACP is asking the appeals court to send the case back for an evidentiary hearing.
- The lawsuit centers on whether lawmakers elected via unconstitutional racial gerrymanders had the authority to place amendments on the ballot.
Three perspectives
Neutral
North Carolina voters will decide next week whether to expand photo ID requirements and lower the state income tax cap.
Positive
NAACP attorney Kym Meyer said she was encouraged that the judges listened to and understood their arguments.
Negative
The NAACP is facing a dismissal of its lawsuit regarding the legitimacy of the lawmakers who proposed previous constitutional amendments.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
