Product similarity makes supply chain disruptions much larger

New simulations show that how easily customers find new suppliers changes how failures spread.

Disruptions spread through supply networks when customers cannot replace the products they lose. A product-specific rule for selecting new suppliers makes cascades after a hub failure four to five times larger than a portfolio-overlap rule.

Researchers used a network of about 77,000 firms and 197,000 supplier-customer edges from the MarkLines database. They ran 119,000 simulations using an agent-based disruption model. This model includes calibrated capacities and inventories.

The model uses a product-specific substitution rule based on the semantic similarity of product names. Network topology determines which firms a shock reaches. Substitutability determines how many of those firms fail.

An index that adds product substitutability to topology identifies 32 of the 50 most damaging suppliers under random disruptions. This index carries over without refitting to a regional scenario modelled on the 2011 Tohoku Earthquake.

Supply network risk assessment should account for product-level substitutability. This means assessments need product data on supply relationships.

Key facts

  • The product-specific rule makes cascades four to five times larger than the portfolio-overlap rule.
  • The factor of increase ranges from 1.2 to 18 under different similarity thresholds.
  • Topology identifies 20 of the 50 most damaging suppliers, while the index identifies 32.

All sections

Edition