Heat transfer between rooms can make energy savings look larger than they are

Testing new heating controls in only part of a building can overestimate how much energy is actually saved.

Testing advanced heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning control in only a few zones can overestimate whole-building savings. This happens because heat drawn from neighboring zones is paid for by their equipment and is not counted.

Researchers simulated a two-story house in West Lafayette, Indiana, over a 90-day heating season. They used receding-horizon model predictive control on the first floor and setpoint control on the second floor.

Thermal zones are parts of a building with specific heating needs. Thermal conductance is the measure of heat transfer between zones. A time-of-use tariff is a type of electricity price that changes over time.

The study used four combinations of electricity tariff and heating plant, including heat pump and electric resistance. The exact correction from a recent theorem recovered the true savings in every case.

The conductance ratio bounds the error from above in all four cases. This bound is tight under a flat tariff and within 3%. It is loose under a time-of-use tariff where savings come from shifting load through thermal mass.

Key facts

  • Heat drawn from neighboring zones can bias savings estimates when controlling only part of a multi-zone building.
  • The error grows with the thermal conductance between controlled and uncontrolled zones.
  • A theorem can recover true savings using building parameters, temperatures, and prices.

All sections

Edition