Measuring control authority in aircraft with many small engines

A new method uses probability to check if distributed electric propulsion provides enough control during the design process.

Researchers have developed a way to measure control authority during the design of aircraft. This method uses probabilistic attainable moment sets to evaluate if a design can meet its needs.

Distributed electric propulsion (DEP) uses many small propulsion units instead of a few large ones. These units are spread across the airframe. Differential thrust from these units can act as an additional control effector. This can specifically affect the yaw axis and may reduce the size of the vertical tail.

Integrated aircraft design combines models for aerodynamics, propulsion, mass, and mission performance. These disciplines are traded against each other in one design loop. For DEP aircraft, part of the control authority comes from the propulsion system. This affects the required size of the tail. This information should be known while the aircraft is being sized.

The attainable moment set (AMS) describes the moments that a suite of effectors can produce. The required moment set (RMS) contains the moments a system must be able to generate. The PAMS is the α\alpha-confidence probabilistic attainable moment set. It is the set of moments that effectors can generate with a probability of at least α\alpha.

The new approach integrates the PAMS into the aircraft sizing loop. Every candidate design is analyzed with the aerodynamic tool AVL. This tool provides the control effectiveness of the converged design. The uncertainty of these low-fidelity models is propagated to the boundary of the set.

The comparison between the PAMS and the RMS provides a margin for every direction in the moment space. It also provides the probability of violating the requirement. This informs the design loop if a configuration has sufficient control authority. It also shows which axes fall short and how this changes with design variables.

The method was demonstrated on a DEP regional aircraft. The signal was used to assess the size of the vertical tail. The measure reflects changes in mass, center of gravity, inertia, and trim state caused by changes to the effectors.

Key facts

  • Distributed electric propulsion uses many small units spread over an airframe.
  • The PAMS accounts for uncertainty in the underlying models.
  • The method evaluates if a design provides enough control authority during the sizing process.

All sections

Edition