Roundabouts and smart signals can reduce traffic delays

New research shows that decentralized traffic systems can sometimes perform better than traditional timed signals.

Researchers found that replacing intersections with roundabouts or using self-organizing signals can lower traffic delays. In a regular grid of roads, changing just the most central intersection reduces delays by 2 to 3% compared to actuated control. Converting every intersection into a roundabout performed better than any signal-based method in a regular grid.

Traffic networks are complex systems where local movements create large patterns like jams. Traditional methods use centralized control to set signal timings based on history. However, these plans often fail because actual traffic demand changes every minute. This mismatch causes unnecessary stops and delays.

The study used SUMO simulations to test different road layouts. They looked at a regular 4×\times4 grid and an irregular version of that grid. They compared roundabouts and self-organizing signals against fixed-time and actuated control. They also tested how these systems handle sudden surges in traffic demand.

Roundabouts use a spatial rule where the shape of the junction dictates how cars move. Self-organizing signals use a temporal rule where software changes lights based on real-time local data. Actuated control is a system that adjusts signal timing based on current traffic flow.

In the irregular network, roundabouts worked best until a critical load was reached. This breakdown happened when the average demand reached about 3.1 times the base load. After this point, self-organizing signals had the lowest delays. These signals were also nearly insensitive to traffic surges.

The study found a slower-is-faster effect in regular grids. Roundabouts at a 40 km/h speed limit matched the average speed of signals at a 50 km/h limit. This suggests that lower speeds can lead to faster overall travel. Travel times in these self-organized flows are also more predictable.

Roundabouts are known to be safer because they reduce crossing paths. Converting signals to roundabouts can result in 35% fewer total collisions. This can lead to 80% fewer injuries and 90% fewer fatal collisions.

Some cities have moved away from roundabouts because they can saturate during rush hour. In these cases, signals might be better at clearing queues. The research notes that the best solution depends on the specific road layout and traffic volume.

Key facts

  • Converting the most central intersection to a roundabout reduces delays by 2 to 3%.
  • Roundabouts at 40 km/h can match the speed of signals at 50 km/h.
  • Self-organizing signals perform best in irregular networks when demand exceeds 3.1 times the base load.
  • Roundabouts can reduce fatal collisions by up to 90%.

All sections

Edition